index 

Yamanoi Kazunori Home

The Care for the Elderly in Sweden and in Japan


 

8.  History of the Elderly Care in Both Countries 
8.1 Comparison of the Elderly Care Development 

Table . 29
Elderly Care Resources in Sweden and in Japan  per 100 Elderly Population(>65)  
(in 1990)  

    JAPAN
 ( 1990 )  
 JAPAN 
( 2000 )
SWEDEN 
( 1990 )
Sheltered Housing 
-
0.5
2.7 
( servicehus )  
Old Age Home 
(0.6)
 *      
(0.6) 
*      
 2.4 (Ålderdomshem )
Nursing Home 
1.1 
1.1
 
2.4 
( sjukhem )
Geriatric Hospital 
 1.0
  0.6 
1.0 
( LåangvårdkIinik )  
Group Living - - 0.3  
Facilities for 
Health Service 
for Elderly *** 
-

1.3 

-

Total 2.l 3.5   8.8 
Home Helper 
0.24
 **    
 0.45 
**    
4.73 
**     
Old Age Home in Japan is the facility for the poor elderly who is physically independent. So this ratio is not included to the TOTAL percentage.  
** number of home helpers per 100 elderly(>65)
*** Facilities for the elderly who do not need to be hospitalized for treatment, but who need functional training, nursing and care for rehabilitation. In general patients can stay here maximum three months. But Actually patients can not move back home so easily.    

 

Step.3  Aging Rate 14-16%
  - Sheltered Housing, Home Health Care, Nursing Homes -
  (1970's in Sweden, 1994-1998 in Japan)  

   
  *1970's(14%-16%) in SWEDEN

In this period in Sweden, the following service spread rapidly.  Home Help, Sheltered Housing, Home Health Care(Primary Care) ,  Nursing Home and so on.  

*1994(14%) - 1998(16%) in Japan

  In this period in Japan, the following service are planed to spread. Home Help, Sheltered Housing, Nursing Homes, Day-Care Centre, Facilities for Health Service for Elderly and so on. Except the facilities for health service for elderly, almost the same service are planed to spread in Sweden and in Japan.  

  It is interesting that the big institutions like nursing homes(four beds in one rooms) are built in Japan. In Sweden also in 1970's many big nursing homes were built and later the quality of life of such big institutions became the problem. I think in Japan we also face the same problem. 10 years later, the big nursing homes(four beds in one room) will be the big problem.

 

Step.4 Aging Rate 17-18%
  - 24 Hours Home Help, Technical Aid, Integration of Home Health Care and Home Help -  
  (1980 s 1990 s in Sweden and 1999-2004 in Japan)  

*1980's(17%) - 1990's(18%) in Sweden

In this period in SWEDEN, the following services spread. Night Patrol, Day-Care Center. Home Health Care, Technical Aid, Group Living, Modern Old Age Home. And the integration between the sociaI service and the heaIth care wiII become very important .  

*1998(17%) - 2004(18%) in Japan

  Through the comparison of both countries, I think that the  elderly care system in each country mainly depends on the aging  rate. So if I can learn the development of the elderly care in  Sweden in 1980's - 1990's. I can roughly find that what kind of elderly care resource will be needed in Japan in 1998 - 2004.  

  For example, night patrol, district nurse system and technical  aids and group living will be needed in Japan also. And the  integration of the health care and the social service will become very important , too. And the QOL at the nursing homes and the  geriatric hospital will be needed as their own "home". The single room at the institutions will be needed.  

  The need of elderly care has become bigger and bigger day by day. But the problem is that the speed of aging in Japan is so quick that it is difficult for the Japanese people to change the  way of thinking and invest more money for the elderly.  

8.2 The Development Process of the Elderly Care

From the comparison in both countries, I can guess that the aging rate is the more important factor which influence the elderly care system than the cultural difference and the national character difference.  

It means t hat at any countries when the society is  industrialized and the aging rate increase, the families become  to unable to take care of the elderly without the help of public  service like Figure.14.  

The aging rate and the extent of the industrialization influence  each other and regulate the society's need about elderly care.  

Figure . 14  The Developvent of the Elderly Care Style

 In other words, the elderly care in Sweden and in Japan develop, in general, with similar development process as follows.

 

  Why the elderly care development process have the similarity in Japan and in Sweden? It is because both Sweden and Japan have the same interest "better quality and less cost". Both countries have the same interest, so the trend will become similar.

 

Table.30 
The Difference of the Elderly Care in Different Society  

Common Society Aged Society
Health Care Hospital Oriented Primary Care Oriente
Institution  Hospital-Like Atmosphere Home-Like Atmosphere
Home Help Only Day-Time. Week Day 24 Hours Every Day
Separate from Home Health Care Cooperate with Home Health Care  
Concept  Length of Life  Quality of Life 
Aim To Survive  To Enjoy Life  

  Through the process in Figure.15 from step.1 to step.4, and  through the development from the elderly care at the common  society and to the elderly care at the aged society in table.29,  the most important point is that the development means not only  the "better quality of life for the elderly" but also the "less  cost" . The Swedish model is called "unique" model, but it has  aimed at the true efficiency, so I think that the Swedish model  is a "general" model for the aged society.  

Of course, it is a discussion whether Japan should provide all  these services by public sector like in Sweden or not. And the percentage of housewives in Japan will not decrease like in Sweden. So I do not think that the Japanese elderly care will  or should be the absolute same as Swedish Model. But by learning  the development process of the Swedish elderly care, I can  understand how much resources are needed for the future elderly care model in Japan.


 back  index  next    home